Protection against hacker attacks and criminal activities is one of the key challenges in the development of future systems. The use of optimal protective measures enables potential illegal intrusions into systems to be identified at an early stage and protects them from harmful actions.
Threat modeling is a structured approach used in cybersecurity. Security mechanisms include identifying, evaluating, prioritizing, and eliminating potential security threats to a system or application. Threat modeling helps develop secure systems by implementing effective countermeasures at an early stage. Threat analysis is now common in all industries, including the automotive and medical industries, with a focus on information security, enterprise risk management, and data security.
Threat modeling is used for:
First, it must be determined what is to be protected (e.g., data, applications, networks). This is the system to be secured. Then, potential attackers must be identified (e.g., hackers, insiders, competitors). This refers to potential attackers of the system to be secured. It is also very important to identify the possible motivations and objectives of the attackers. For example, hackers could manipulate patient results in order to damage the reputation of a medical device manufacturer. In a bank, hackers could access customer data in order to make illegal cash withdrawals. This defines the impact of potential threats on the system.
The objectives are defined. A decision is made as to whether, for example, potential vulnerabilities need to be identified, the security architecture improved, and legal requirements complied with. Defining and setting clear objectives is an important first step in the threat modeling process. The objectives vary depending on specific requirements and context. Possible objectives are:
The definition of these objectives guides the further course of threat modeling and determines which methods and tools are used.
Here are some of the most popular tools that support the threat modeling process:
There are several established frameworks that support the threat modeling process. Here are the best known:
For beginners, STRIDE is often the easiest way to get started in threat modeling because it offers a clear structure and is easy to understand. It helps identify and address potential vulnerabilities early on, resulting in more secure systems.
STRIDE stands for the following categories of threats:
Data flow diagrams play a central role in analyzing and documenting the architecture of a system. They provide a visual representation of the data movements within an application or network and illustrate how information flows between different components, users, or external devices.
By creating a detailed data flow diagram, developers and security experts gain valuable insights into the structure and functioning of a system. This enables them to identify critical interfaces where sensitive data is processed or forwarded. By identifying such potential vulnerabilities at an early stage, targeted measures can be taken to secure these points.
A well-structured data flow diagram not only serves as technical documentation, but is also an essential basis for a sound security assessment. It helps to systematically analyze threat scenarios and develop effective security strategies based on them. Particular focus should be placed on areas where unsecured data transfers take place or where external influences could potentially compromise the system.
In addition, a clear and understandable representation of data flows facilitates collaboration between different actors. Developers, security officers, and specialist departments can use the diagram to better understand how data is moved within the system and where additional security measures are required. Regular review and updating of the data flow diagram ensures that it always corresponds to the current system requirements and threat situation.
The identification of threats is a crucial step in threat modeling. In order to detect security risks at an early stage, it is necessary to comprehensively analyze the entire system and apply structured methods or proven frameworks. This systematic approach makes it possible to identify potential attack points and vulnerabilities before they can be exploited by attackers.
A proven model for identifying threats is, for example, the STRIDE model described above.
Graphical example of the “elevation of privilege” attack type
For the standard-compliant development of products, e.g., medical devices, classification characteristics must be defined as part of risk management to assess the probability and severity of the threat.
Definition of classification characteristics:
Classification characteristics are specific criteria used to assess the probability of a risk occurring and the potential severity of the impact of that risk. These characteristics enable an objective and traceable assessment of risks and form the basis for prioritizing risk management measures.
Examples of classification characteristics:
Process for defining classification characteristics:
Regulatory requirements:
According to ISO 14971, the international standard for risk management of medical devices, manufacturers are required to systematically identify, evaluate, and control risks. The standard emphasizes the importance of defining severity classes and establishing criteria for assessing the probability of risks. A structured approach to defining classification characteristics supports compliance with this standard and facilitates the performance of risk analyses.
Conclusion
Careful definition and application of classification criteria for assessing the probability and severity of risks are fundamental steps in the risk management process for medical devices. They help to identify potential hazards at an early stage and implement appropriate risk mitigation measures to ensure the safety and effectiveness of the products.
Once potential threats have been identified, the next step is to assess the associated risks. This is done by analyzing two key factors: the probability of occurrence and the potential extent of damage (severity). A risk matrix is often used to present these factors in a structured way.
A risk matrix helps to visually capture risks and prioritize them more easily. Threats are classified into categories such as “low,” “medium,” or “high” based on their probability and potential damage. This categorization makes it possible to allocate resources specifically to the most important security measures and address the most urgent vulnerabilities first.
By prioritizing risks, targeted countermeasures can be implemented efficiently. Critical security gaps should be addressed first to minimize potential damage to the system or organization. Various measures can be taken, such as implementing additional security controls, training employees, or introducing monitoring systems for early detection of attacks.
The priority of the countermeasure is determined according to the risk value.
To ensure the security of a system, it is crucial to mitigate identified threats with appropriate countermeasures. Basic security mechanisms include:
Threat modeling is an essential part of software and system security. To maximize its effectiveness, it should not be viewed as a one-time task, but rather as an ongoing process integrated into the entire development cycle.
Early integration into the development process
The optimal time to create a threat model is as early as possible, ideally during the planning phase of a project. By analyzing potential threats early on, security risks can be identified and appropriate risk mitigation measures implemented at an early stage. This helps avoid costly security issues later on.
Continuous maintenance and adaptation
Threat landscapes are constantly changing, which is why one-time modeling is not sufficient. Regular updates to the threat model ensure that new threats can be identified and addressed. This means that the model should be reviewed and adapted not only during initial development, but also whenever significant changes are made to the system.
Collaboration between different teams
A successful threat model is the result of close collaboration between various stakeholders. Developers, security experts, and specialist departments should continuously exchange information to ensure a comprehensive analysis of potential risks. This interdisciplinary collaboration leads to a more in-depth security assessment and better protective measures.
Regular training and awareness
General security awareness among all responsible parties is one of the most effective lines of defense against cyber threats. Through continuous awareness measures and training, all participants can expand their knowledge of current threats and best practices. This enables actors to identify potential vulnerabilities earlier and respond appropriately.
By following these best practices, you can establish sustainable and effective threat modeling that not only improves system security but also strengthens cybersecurity awareness throughout the organization.
Threat modeling is a structured and proactive approach to protecting systems against potential security threats at an early stage. By systematically analyzing vulnerabilities, assessing risks, and prioritizing appropriate countermeasures, security gaps can be identified and remedied during the development phase. This not only improves the security architecture, but also saves time and money in the long term.
The use of established frameworks such as STRIDE, DREAD, PASTA, or VAST, as well as specialized tools (e.g., Microsoft Threat Modeling Tool, OWASP Threat Dragon), supports the efficient implementation of modeling. STRIDE is particularly suitable for beginners, as it provides a clear categorization of the most common threats.
Key elements of the process include describing the system, visualizing it using data flow diagrams, conducting a structured threat analysis, and prioritizing defensive measures based on risk. This is supplemented by defining classification characteristics, which are particularly important in regulated industries such as medical technology, in line with standards such as ISO 14971.
However, threat modeling is not a one-time event, but should be integrated as a continuous process throughout the entire life cycle of a system. This is the only way to ensure that new threats are identified and addressed in a timely manner. Close cooperation between all parties involved and continuous training and awareness-raising on IT security are equally crucial.
Overall, threat modeling plays a key role in making systems more resilient, compliant with the law, and secure in the long term, while also creating a common security foundation within development teams and organizations.
You are currently viewing a placeholder content from OpenStreetMap. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
You need to load content from hCaptcha to submit the form. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
You are currently viewing a placeholder content from Google Maps. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.